Comments on: Giving Up Don http://BestForexEA.com/2009/03/giving-up-don/ Searching for The Best Forex EA Around Tue, 07 Sep 2010 12:21:40 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.0.1 By: Casey http://BestForexEA.com/2009/03/giving-up-don/comment-page-1/#comment-150 Casey Wed, 01 Apr 2009 00:56:25 +0000 http://BestForexEA.com/?p=195#comment-150 Thanks Dr Stan for visiting my site.. You don't have to be sorry. If one is trading base on a robot, then it has absolutely nothing to do with sound fundamentals. Having said that.... your theory that every trade should turn profit... interesting... Care to share more information about that? For me if an EA is not profitable, whether it is sound fundamentals or not. I would dump it. I am and still am ignorant about forex market. I guess my journey here will continue to help me learn more. But so far, I do not have the time to monitor market both technically and fundamentally. I spend that time blabbing about EA and testing robots... Well, once I found my EA and become more profitable. Leave my job then maybe I'll look into trading manual. A lot of people think that trading manually is the key to higher profitability. Will want to experience that soon... :) Hopefully my journey with Firebird EA which is partially semi automatic will give me a glimpse of that... Thanks Dr Stan for visiting my site.. You don’t have to be sorry. If one is trading base on a robot, then it has absolutely nothing to do with sound fundamentals.

Having said that…. your theory that every trade should turn profit… interesting…

Care to share more information about that?

For me if an EA is not profitable, whether it is sound fundamentals or not. I would dump it.

I am and still am ignorant about forex market. I guess my journey here will continue to help me learn more. But so far, I do not have the time to monitor market both technically and fundamentally.

I spend that time blabbing about EA and testing robots… Well, once I found my EA and become more profitable. Leave my job then maybe I’ll look into trading manual.

A lot of people think that trading manually is the key to higher profitability. Will want to experience that soon… :)

Hopefully my journey with Firebird EA which is partially semi automatic will give me a glimpse of that…

]]> By: SNGB240 http://BestForexEA.com/2009/03/giving-up-don/comment-page-1/#comment-149 SNGB240 Tue, 31 Mar 2009 20:38:09 +0000 http://BestForexEA.com/?p=195#comment-149 I have to agree with you. I stopped using it too. Don claims you can just set it and leave it alone! If he said we had to learn and constantly watch fundamentals, etc. (like some are saying in response to criticisms of this robot) than he should have said so. Most of us are too busy to do this that's why we buy the robot (which is also its sales pitch). It's misleading otherwise... BTW - I'm a doctor and have sound fundamentals. This robot still managed clean me out of my accounts on three occasions. In theory, if you leave your trades open and have unlimited finances and time, of course your trades will eventually rebound. So what Don claims can be applied to every trade principle and robot in the history of mankind. But then why have a robot at all? Why just not arbitrarily open trades and let them run until they profit - even if it takes forever. Theoretically, every trade should turn profit between now and the end of time. Sorry, this is not a sound fundamentals, it breaks the cardinal rules of trading, and will eventually bust you long before the end of time. Dr. Stan I have to agree with you. I stopped using it too. Don claims you can just set it and leave it alone! If he said we had to learn and constantly watch fundamentals, etc. (like some are saying in response to criticisms of this robot) than he should have said so. Most of us are too busy to do this that’s why we buy the robot (which is also its sales pitch). It’s misleading otherwise…

BTW – I’m a doctor and have sound fundamentals. This robot still managed clean me out of my accounts on three occasions. In theory, if you leave your trades open and have unlimited finances and time, of course your trades will eventually rebound. So what Don claims can be applied to every trade principle and robot in the history of mankind. But then why have a robot at all? Why just not arbitrarily open trades and let them run until they profit – even if it takes forever. Theoretically, every trade should turn profit between now and the end of time.

Sorry, this is not a sound fundamentals, it breaks the cardinal rules of trading, and will eventually bust you long before the end of time.
Dr. Stan

]]>